Hayfield Secondary School’s football team received a two-year suspension from the Virginia High School League (VHSL) for athlete recruitment misconduct, prompting harsh criticism from the community and an investigation from FCPS.
The scandal came to light in June after allegations emerged that new head football coach Darryl Overton recruited athletes from his former school, Freedom High School. A VHSL investigation found that the total number of students recruited in violation of VHSL rules amounted to 14 from Freedom, with an additional 17 from schools across the DMV. The Freedom Eagles were the VHSL state champions in 2023, while Hayfield lost in the first round.
The coaches went as far as classifying two transfer students as homeless to immediately enroll them into Hayfield. However, on Nov. 18, a hearing at the Fairfax County Circuit Court declared that the team’s practices were within the bounds of VHSL’s rules. The judge issued an injunction to stop VHSL’s decision and lift the suspension. Simultaneously, FCPS launched an internal investigation with The McCammon Group, a local law firm that specializes in arbitration.
The results of the investigation concluded that the recruitment practices used were lawful. The consecutive court ruling and internal investigation result, both excusing the problematic recruitment methods, fueled community anger.
“An internal investigation was actually done over the summer with internal HR folks as well as a former deputy attorney general of Virginia, Cynthia Hudson,” at-large school board member Ryan McElveen said. “The investigation looked into residency issues, and it came back saying that there were no issues and that we could proceed with the season.”
On Nov. 25, Mount Vernon District School Board Representative Mateo Dunne released a joint statement on the Hayfield controversy with McElveen and Mason District Representative Ricardy Anderson to criticize the county’s investigative processes, contending that the review was flawed.
“The three of us actually called for a more robust internal investigation at the Aug. 29 school board meeting, and that measure was defeated 9-3,” McElveen said. “We wanted someone with zero ties to FCPS to come in and take a look, and that’s what we’re pushing for now.”
Still, persistent controversies caused Hayfield to withdraw from the VHSL playoffs on Nov. 25. The same day, Superintendent Michelle Reid revealed that new evidence was brought to the attention of the school board. The series of text messages were from Hayfield’s director of student activities (DSA), Monty Fritts, who resigned from his position effective Dec. 2.
“I like to win and make money,” Fritts said in the text conversation. “My principal really wants Overton. If they are homeless, nothing can happen.”
The ongoing issues caused some community members to call for Reid’s resignation from her position as superintendent. At the Dec. 5 school board meeting, Reid apologized for the scandal. As a result of the new evidence, the FCPS school board unanimously voted for a comprehensive external review by an independent law firm for every athletic program in FCPS, starting with Hayfield.
“It’s not just the issues at Hayfield, but also the systemic issues,” Dunne said. “I have received concerns over other sports at other high schools in the past couple of weeks. What it showed is [while Hayfield] has received the most immediate attention, it is not the only problem. We haven’t actually fixed the problem because we need to address the larger disease.”
The Hayfield scandal has led staff and students across FCPS to question the extreme competitiveness in school sports.
“Especially at the high school level, we’re teaching a lot more than just winning,” McLean DSA Greg Miller said. “We’re trying to teach life lessons at the high school level so that students are prepared for life both in and out of sports.”
Categories:
FCPS fumbles Hayfield scandal
Controversies over Fairfax County football team suspension lead to countywide investigation
Donate to The Highlander
$310
$1000
Contributed
Our Goal
Your donation supports the McLean High School's independent, award-winning news publication.